Which Tire Sealant Brand Wins?
A head-to-head test of 4 tire sealant options with the measured results for each. See how they ranked and watch the full test video.
MultiSeal
Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
The measured results
Every number below is read straight from the test. Scroll sideways to see all measurements. Products are listed in the order they finished.
| Product | Contents/SDS | Initial small puncture test | Freeze test (-15F for 24 hours) | Larger puncture test (1/4 in bolt) | Severe puncture test (3/8 in landscape spike, tested only on this brand) | Corrosion test (untreated steel, zinc washer, aluminum, 24 hours) | Cleanup ease | Application |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1MultiSeal | not much information available, contains propylene glycol; gooier and thicker with larger particles than Tire Slime, forms a glue like consistency | sealed the drywall-screw sized hole, no leak seen, held 30 lbs of pressure after about 15 hours | did not freeze, still a gel, ranked best of the 4, described as very impressive | sealed the enlarged hole, no leak after a 5 mile drive | stopped the leak, tire held pressure, per the manufacturer's own claim of handling punctures up to 1/2 inch | no visible rust on the zinc washer or aluminum; some color change on the untreated steel that the host could not confirm was rust or not | ranked easiest to clean up of the 4 products | required 32 oz for the full-size tire, more volume than the other products, but flowed a lot easier than Tire Slime |
| 2Tire Slime$8.99 | glycerol, attapulgite, cellulose, and quartz; small black particles visible, thick and pasty | sealed the drywall-screw sized hole, no leak seen, held 30 lbs of pressure after about 15 hours | ranked third of the 4, still seemed like it would work but not as good a gel as MultiSeal or TireJect | sealed the enlarged hole, described as a very impressive performance after a 5 mile drive | not tested | no visible rust, black specs described as normal for the product | ranked second easiest to clean up | took the longest amount of time and the most effort of the 4 products to apply |
| 3TireJect | propylene glycol and natural rubber latex (an allergy consideration); no particles seen but some globs, becomes glue like very quickly | sealed the drywall-screw sized hole, no leak seen, held 30 lbs of pressure after about 15 hours | ranked second of the 4, still in a gel like state | sealed the original hole and continued to hold after the hole was enlarged and driven 5 miles | not tested | showed surface oxidation and, after cleaning, some surface rust starting lower on the steel, the only product with a clearly stated rust result | ranked hardest to clean up of the 4 products, leaves a coating that will not come off with water and dries stringy | close second easiest to apply behind Fix-a-Flat, small pouches empty out quickly |
| 4Fix-a-Flat$6.83 | tetrafluoropropene, glycerol, and cellulose; no visible particles, host was unsure how the product mechanically seals a hole | failed, continued leaking significantly; a second can was applied and still failed; lost pressure from 30 lbs down to about 4 lbs overnight | ranked worst (fourth) of the 4, froze solid | not tested | not tested | no visible rust | ranked third easiest to clean up, described as not turning into as big a mess as some other products since it does not become slime | ranked easiest of the 4 products to apply |
How it was tested
- initial small puncture seal test (drywall screw sized hole, pressure check after about 15 hours)
- off-road driving test (about 4 miles) since one product is off-road only
- corrosion test on untreated steel, a zinc coated washer, and aluminum over 24 hours
- freeze test at 15 degrees below zero Fahrenheit for 24 hours
- composition/particle test, straining each product to see what solids or particles are inside
- larger puncture test using a 1/4 inch bolt to enlarge the original hole, re-tested after a 5 mile drive
- severe puncture test using a 3/8 inch landscape spike, run only on MultiSeal per its own larger-puncture claim
- final teardown of each tire to inspect the sealant and repaired area inside
- cleanup ease and application ease comparison, plus price
“So, is Tire Slime the best? In my opinion, it is the best for on-road purposes. However, MultiSeal seems like it's an overall better product for off-road purposes.”
Data notes and caveats
This video ends with two separate per-use-case picks rather than one overall winner: Tire Slime is named best for on-road use, and MultiSeal is named the overall better product for off-road use, so winner and runnerUp are left null per the per-use-case convention and both picks are preserved in the corresponding products' notes. TireJect is praised as working fairly well but is not named the top pick in either category. Fix-a-Flat is the clear last place finisher, failing its very first small puncture test across 4 separate cans and therefore excluded from the later larger and severe puncture tests. MultiSeal and TireJect prices are never stated as exact figures, only described as 'quite a bit more expensive' than Tire Slime ($8.99) and Fix-a-Flat ($6.83); recorded as null per the never-invent-a-price rule rather than estimated. The severe puncture (3/8 inch landscape spike) test is explicitly run only on MultiSeal because it is the only product to claim it can handle punctures up to 1/2 inch, a genuine test-design choice rather than a caption gap. Chapters align very precisely with the video's actual test sequence per brand and test type.