2023 test5 productsJump Starters & Car Power
Which Car Battery Restoration Brand Wins?
A head-to-head test of 5 car battery restoration options with the measured results for each. See how they ranked and watch the full test video.
Ranked first
Duralast
Check price on Amazon
Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
The measured results
Every number below is read straight from the test. Scroll sideways to see all measurements. Products are listed in the order they finished.
| Product | Rating | Restoration_method | Before | After | Real_world_test | After_epsom_salt | After_welder_followup |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1Duralast | 825 cranking amps, 660 cold cranking amps | stick welder (Harbor Freight titanium 225 inverter welder, about $320), 6 charge cycles of 5 minutes each at 70 to 85 amps with cooldowns between cycles | 204 cranking amps (tester recommends replacement), state of health 21%, internal resistance 19.05, all cells below 1.2 specific gravity, load test around 200 amps | 446 cranking amps, state of health 46%, internal resistance 9.01, hydrometer readings improved to roughly 1.19 to 1.25 across cells, load test started around 600 amps and dropped to about 425 amps after 8 seconds | not tested | not tested | not tested |
| 2Autocraft | 1,000 cranking amps, 4 years old | stick welder at a higher 100 amps (versus 70-85 amps used on the other batteries), 6 charge cycles with cooldowns between cycles | only 62 cranking amps, state of health 6% (the worst of all 5 batteries tested), internal resistance 62.5 (the worst of all 5), one cell (cell five) reading very low on the hydrometer | 961 cranking amps, close to its full 1,000 rating, state of health 81%, internal resistance 4.26 (the best final internal resistance of all 5 batteries), load test dropped to about 900 amps | successfully spun over Cousin Eddie's Farmall B tractor with a big block 454 engine for about 13 seconds; checked again after sitting overnight and was still holding a charge, performing as well as the day before | not tested | not tested |
| 3unnamed battery, approximately 12 years old | 930 cranking amps | battery desulfator gadget, about $20, sends a continuous 2-amp pulse through the battery; tested again after nearly a week | 714 cranking amps, state of health 64%, internal resistance 5.72 milliohms, cells at specific gravity 1.24 to 1.25, voltage 12.7 | 613 cranking amps (worse than before), internal resistance 6.63 (worse than before) | not tested | not tested | not tested |
| 4unnamed battery, approximately 8 years old | not tested | Epsom salt: battery acid drained, neutralized with baking soda and water, flushed with distilled water, refilled with an Epsom salt and distilled water mix, then charged for 12 hours; when that failed, the battery was also zapped with the stick welder for 6 cycles as a follow-up | 599 to 600 cranking amps, state of health 50%, internal resistance 6.79 milliohms, voltage 12.7 | not tested | not tested | 51 cranking amps (much worse), voltage dropped to 11.21, internal resistance 74.4 (much worse) | roughly 59 amps on the electronic tester; load test started around 600 amps and dropped to just over 200 amps |
| 5unnamed battery from an old Ford Ranger, over 10 years old, badly sulfated | not tested | stick welder, 6 charge cycles, followed by an overnight manual battery charger session at 10 amps | 7.3 volts, would not hold a charge, essentially unusable | 424 cranking amps on the electronic tester (still recommends replacement), state of health 46%, internal resistance 9.47; load tester showed a better result, starting at 800 amps and dropping to about 600 amps after 10 seconds, described as 'pretty good shape' | successfully started the Ford Ranger 5 times back to back; however, when checked again the next day the battery had already dropped to just over 10 volts and was described as still in bad condition | not tested | not tested |
How it was tested
- baseline diagnostics on each battery: electronic battery tester (Foxwell BT705) for cranking amps, state of health (SOH), and internal resistance; hydrometer readings of electrolyte specific gravity per cell; a load tester applying an actual electric load
- restoration via stick (arc) welder applying repeated 5-minute charge cycles at 70 to 100 amps with cooldown periods between cycles
- restoration via a low-cost electronic battery desulfator applying a continuous 2-amp pulse over roughly a week
- restoration via draining the battery, neutralizing acid with baking soda, and refilling with an Epsom salt and distilled water solution
- real-world test of restored batteries starting actual vehicles/engines (a Ford Ranger and a Farmall B tractor with a big block 454)
- overnight charge-retention check on the two best-performing restored batteries
“the welder helped the other three batteries and in one case made the battery about as good as new. So, I have to admit, I'm really surprised that the process actually works.”